The Allure of the "Mob Don"

Forget abstract criticisms of Trump. Connect emotionally with voters rather than relying on abstract warnings.We should demonstrate how democracy delivers real security and belonging.

I recently stumbled upon a concise description of Donald Trump's leadership style: "Trump's leadership style echoes a mob Don: loyalty demanded, dissent punished, deals made in back rooms, a cult of personality, and a disregard for established norms. He weaponizes rhetoric, cultivates fear, and blurs lines between personal gain and public office." This observation resonated with my own fascination with the mob archetype, fueled by podcasts and classic mob films. (My dad used to drive a delivery truck for a laundry business earlier owned by Mr. Capone-growing up in Chicago, it was impossible not to be fascinated by organized crime)

It led me to wonder: why does this "mob Don" persona hold such appeal for certain voters? It's not simply about chaos; it's about a perceived order, albeit a distinctly unconventional one.

The mob boss, in their twisted way, represents a figure of decisive action. In a political landscape viewed as gridlocked and ineffectual, the Don "gets things done." This archetype offers:

• Protection and Belonging: A sense of community for those feeling marginalized.

• Direct Action: Bypassing bureaucratic red tape for swift results.

• Clear Hierarchy: A defined structure with unambiguous authority.

• Loyalty Rewards: Access and benefits for unwavering support.

• Strength Against Enemies: A projection of power against perceived threats.

For many, this isn't disturbing; it's a refreshing break from perceived political stagnation. Trump's aggressive rhetoric and disregard for traditional norms are interpreted as authenticity, a willingness to fight for their interests. (This also explains the failure of weak Democratic leadership to have had much traction over recent years.)

The "strongman" approach, while unsettling to some, resonates with those who prioritize results over process. When the existing system feels broken, a figure who promises decisive action, even if unorthodox, can be incredibly appealing. This is not to condone the behaviors, but to understand the appeal of a figure who operates outside of the normal political constraints. Again, I confess I watched both the Untouchables on TV and most movies about the “family”.

Our fascination with the Godfather and mob boss figures reveals a potential political lesson: people are drawn to perceived strength, loyalty, and a defiance of conventional systems, even if those qualities are rooted in morally ambiguous behavior. This affection highlights a desire for leaders who project power and offer a sense of belonging, tapping into primal instincts for protection and order outside traditional structures. How many movies or books have competing groups (the family, law enforcement, government, etc.) in dealing with organized crime resort to writing letters to complain about the other side? Now, compare and contrast those examples of decisive action with US Rep Jeffries press conferences or Sen. Schumer writing a letter to our President complaining about policies.

Lesson of the day.